Top workflow challenges for personal lines brokerages

Running a personal lines brokerage today is about much more than managing renewals and sending reminders. Brokers are juggling rising client expectations, tighter margins, and the ever-present risk of errors. The manual workflows that once worked are showing their cracks, and the consequences can be costly.

From manual renewal processes to inefficient communication, these are common challenges that most insurance brokerages face. They not only slow down service but also affect client retention, revenue, and overall broker satisfaction. Let’s take a look at the biggest pain points they face today,  and where AI-powered automation for insurance can create relief.

‍

Manual, labour-intensive renewal reviews

Renewals are the backbone of a brokerage’s book of business. They represent a good portion of revenue and play a big role in client retention. But the process of reviewing them is often overwhelming; it’s time-consuming, inconsistent, and prone to human error. Many brokers take on the impossible task of reviewing 100% of renewals just to uncover the 20% that truly need attention. Others swing to the opposite extreme, only looking at what they consider “high priority” files and letting the rest slide through in hopes that clients will simply renew on their own.

Neither approach works for long. Renewals build up, leaving clients who are facing steep premium increases or missing critical coverages without timely outreach. That delay not only increases E&O risk, it also chips away at retention and leaves revenue opportunities on the table.

This is where AI renewal automation can change the equation. With Quandri’s Renewal Reviews, renewals are analyzed directly in the broker management system (BMS). Year-over-year changes, missing coverages, and client-specific insights are surfaced automatically. Instead of wading through hundreds of files, brokers can see exactly which accounts are high-risk and prioritize them the same day they download. The result is a more consistent, accurate, and proactive renewal review process that protects clients while saving brokers hours of manual work.

‍

Inefficient client communication

Client outreach is another area where many brokerages struggle. Communication tends to be reactive, inconsistent, and too often generic. In practice, brokers only connect with 20–30% of their clients, leaving the majority without any proactive engagement. For clients, that silence can feel like neglect.

The impact goes beyond poor optics. When clients don’t hear from their broker, they’re more likely to shop around for alternatives. Retention drops, and the brokerage misses crucial opportunities to show its value beyond just comparing prices. Adding to the challenge is the time it takes to craft context-rich, policy-specific emails that are valuable to clients — drafting a single renewal email can take 15–20 minutes. When multiplied across hundreds of accounts, that workload quickly overwhelms even the most diligent teams.

The good news is, there’s a way to turn this communication gap into a strength. With Quandri’s Connect capability, personalized, policy-specific outreach becomes not only possible but scalable. Instead of spending valuable time drafting repetitive emails, brokers can quickly review and send automatically generated professional communications that address each client’s unique coverage. Every message reinforces the broker’s role as a trusted advisor, builds confidence in the relationship, and ultimately helps retain more clients.

‍

Identifying upsell and cross-sell opportunities

Every brokerage wants to grow revenue while protecting clients, but too often the visibility just isn’t there to make that happen. Upsell and cross-sell opportunities hide in the details of renewal data, and when those insights are buried in policy documents or scattered across systems, brokers struggle to see the full picture. Without clear data, it’s almost impossible to segment your book of business and focus on the right clients at the right time.

The result is a lose-lose situation. Clients may remain underinsured without realizing it, and the brokerage misses out on meaningful opportunities to demonstrate value and strengthen relationships. For many teams, the sheer volume of renewals makes it unrealistic to serve every client with equal attention using manual workflows. That means revenue potential is left untapped, and brokers can feel like they’re always playing catch-up instead of providing proactive advice.

This is where automated personal-lines renewals come into play. With AI policy renewal reviews running in the background, brokerages can uncover upsell opportunities directly in the BMS. Coverage gaps and potential add-ons are flagged automatically, giving brokers clear direction for client conversations. Whether it’s increasing liability limits, adding loss of use coverage, or bundling accounts, the broker enters the discussion with actionable insights. That not only drives revenue but also positions the broker as a trusted advisor who ensures clients have the right protection in place.

‍

High administrative overhead and staffing costs

Manual workflows don’t just eat up hours, they demand people. Every renewal that requires manual checking or rekeying adds to the administrative load. Over time, that load becomes a staffing problem. Brokerages are forced to hire and train more staff — or outsource the work completely — just to keep pace with repetitive tasks like policy comparisons, data entry, and follow-ups. The pressure to scale never really stops, and leadership is left with two unappealing options: accept a decline in service quality or keep adding people to plug the gaps.

Neither path is good for profitability. As costs rise, margins shrink. And the cycle repeats year after year. But automation changes that equation. 

With AI working 24/7 and handling repetitive tasks in the background, brokers can focus where they’re most valuable: advising clients, building relationships, and uncovering new opportunities. Instead of stretching teams thin, automation enables brokerages to maximize the potential of their existing talent, all while maintaining consistent service quality.

‍

Data fragmentation and inconsistent workflows

Data fragmentation is another silent challenge for brokerages. Completing a single renewal often means toggling between systems, digging through PDFs, scanning email threads, and updating records in the BMS. Every handoff between platforms is a chance for something to be missed, duplicated, or delayed.

That fragmentation doesn’t just slow things down; it also creates inconsistencies. Some brokers follow one process, others follow another, and leadership is left without a reliable way to track performance or measure results. Without consistent workflows, reporting is incomplete, errors creep in, and it becomes nearly impossible to demonstrate the full value the brokerage delivers to clients.

This is where automation helps stitch everything together. With tools like Quandri’s Requoting capability, policy data is pulled directly from the BMS, new market quotes are generated automatically, and results flow back into Epic without the manual juggling act. That consistency means brokers always have accurate information at their fingertips, leadership receives clearer reporting, and clients enjoy a faster, more professional experience.

‍

Moving forward with AI-powered automation

The top workflow challenges — manual renewals, inefficient communication, missed upsells, high administrative costs, and data fragmentation — aren’t new, but they’re growing more urgent due to a lack of new talent entering the workforce, staff losses due to retirement, and attrition. Left unchecked, they create risks that can erode client trust and hurt profitability.

Brokerages that embrace AI renewal automation and workflow intelligence position themselves to stay competitive. By adopting tools like Quandri’s Renewal Intelligence Platform, they can save hours, reduce risk, and deliver better client experiences at scale.

Explore how Quandri can help your brokerage transform renewals with automation. Book a demo today.